50 Comments
User's avatar
Patrick M. Ohana's avatar

Hell, no! One copied the other and subverted almost everything. One believes in life and the other in murder. One invents and the other destroys.

Expand full comment
Jane Stuart's avatar

Certainly not.

Expand full comment
Esser Agaroth's avatar

Well stated.

Expand full comment
Tanto Minchiata's avatar

Enlightening and soundly reasoned.

Expand full comment
Leslie's avatar

Excellent article. Thank you. 🙏

Expand full comment
Allen Zeesman's avatar

Thank you. Where do I get the supposed original story please?

Expand full comment
Won't Be Silent's avatar

excellent!

Expand full comment
Al Mustafa's avatar

Just to note the legend of Abrahamic genealogy does not include all Arabs. It is concerned with Adnanites also known as Arabicising Arabs. The traditional genealogy claims that Arab Arabs (Qahtanites) originate from Yemen.

Expand full comment
Dandan Prager's avatar

To see Jews as ethnic or religious in the lineage of the abrhamic faiths esraes what being Jewish is. It's being a part of a unique civilization.

https://open.substack.com/pub/dandanprager/p/the-last-blind-spot-of-the-west-the?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=1z5qzb

Expand full comment
Mark Urho's avatar

Precisely 🔥🔥🔥The Third Temple and the Kingdom of Israel (Davidic Dynasty) are ETERNAL and Sanhedrin is also in the Third Temple. Final peace all over the world comes after Shechinah is dwelling in the Third Temple on Mount Moriah in Jerusalem Very Soon Baruch HaShem .

Expand full comment
Paul Brett's avatar

Isaac and Ishmael were half brothers both of their descendants are of Abraham

Muslims are a religion, not a race.

Jews are one of the Tribes of Jacob/Israel Judah. And are Israelites, a race.

Two different things.

Expand full comment
Paul Solomon's avatar

In anthropology the concept of “race” has been thoroughly discredited.

Expand full comment
Paul Brett's avatar

Nevertheless…. Facts will always remain Facts

Expand full comment
Paul Solomon's avatar

My point there was that the definition of “facts” evolves and changes.

Expand full comment
Paul Brett's avatar

Historic Facts Are What They Were and Are and Can Never Change. Or be changed by opinions. Just as No One Can Change Who Your’s or My Parents are, today or in a 1000 years time, now can they? 🤷‍♂️ what anyone “chooses to believe”otherwise, can Never Change This Fact in your case or mine as to who our parents Are.

Cheers

Expand full comment
Paul Solomon's avatar

Who your parents are is and will remain a fact. Race, not a fact: rather it a construct that was valid at one time, and not permanent - eg Nazis regarded the Aryan race as incontrovertible fact, but it was discredited and revised by future academic studies. Another example: an isolated African tribe may (and does) have almost identical DNA as a tribe in Mongolia, and vastly different culture, but both belong to the same biological “race” - Homo sapiens.

Expand full comment
Paul Brett's avatar

Mate, you are in denial of reality. Are there or are there Not Distinguishable Races on Planet Earth. Next you’re going to try to tell me I’m a Chinese Native American Islander 🤦‍♂️ there are Various Human Races dude and Colours. No one even needs an elementary education to understand That. Anyone who cannot admit it is Blind to Reality. And their argument is as ridiculous as saying an Eagle is a Cockatoo just because they’d both birds. Don’t even bother replying, your premise is absurdly flawed and irrationally incorrect, and UnFactual. 💨

Expand full comment
Paul Solomon's avatar

So a fact in 1970 may in 2025 not be regarded as still a fact…….

Expand full comment
Paul Solomon's avatar

“Race” is a social construct not a biological grouping with shared characteristics. Maybe google race in anthropology if interested.

Expand full comment
Alan Mairson's avatar

I’m afraid you’ve missed the point:

Expand full comment
Sarah's avatar

Brilliant article some of this l knew but I have learnt a more today. Thank you

Expand full comment
Elliott Steinberg's avatar

Excellent piece!

Expand full comment
Hava Rahimian's avatar

Amen 🙏

Expand full comment